How does registering with a GP near your child’s school benefit you? Question to CEO of Patients Association

28/6/14

Dear Katherine Murphy,

I am a GP in Tower Hamlets and have been following the Government’s policy regarding GP practice boundaries with some bewilderment over the past 4 years. I became aware that the Patients Association was also keen to abolish GP practice boundaries in the interests of giving patients more ‘choice’. You will of course be aware that the policy will be rolled out in England, on a voluntary basis, from October 2014.

My difficulty has been that the proponents of this policy do not seem to take into account some very practical problems inherent in the policy, and have made claims for the benefits of such a model which simply do not add up.

One suggested benefit will be that patients will be able to register at a practice near their child’s school. The Department of Health mentioned this in their December 2011 launch of the Choose Your GP pilot, you mentioned it in your Huffington Post posting in March 2013, it is mentioned in the first section of the Proposal by the team who then evaluated the pilot, and it has been repeated in the press.

I question the wisdom of this proposal and have asked Jeremy Hunt, the Department of Health, and NHS England the questions below, but they have not answered me. Because you have also gone on the record publicly proposing this as one of the incentives, can you please give an answer to the following questions:

a. what benefit accrues to a child or parent(s) by registering with a GP practice near their child’s school? What might they be hoping to gain from this? Does this mean a parent registering with the practice, or the child, or both? Would all the children of the family register with the practice? Would both parents, in two parents families, register with the practice?

b. how would this work from a practical point of view? When would they want to be seen? How would they make appointments?

c. what, if any, are the possible risks or drawbacks with this arrangement?

I would be grateful for your comments on this.

 

With best wishes,

George

The Tredegar Practice
35 St Stephens Road
London
E3 5JD

*

24/7/14

I have not heard from Katherine Murphy or the Patients Association. I wonder why….

Is it the same reason why the Department of Health has not answered these questions, or NHS England?

*

12/10/14

I have just sent the following email to the Patients Association:

Dear Katherine Murphy,

I sent you the email above on 28/6/14. I have not received a reply, so I am trying again. I will send this in the post as well in case there is some glitch in the system.

Best wishes,

George

The Tredegar Practice
35 St Stephens Road
London
E3 5JD

[the above items sent in Royal Mail 24/10/14]

*

My email to The Patients Association in June 2011.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: