I’m just back from a day’s workshop at the Royal College of General Practitioners. The title: Troubling Patients in Troubling Times. This was a joint venture by the APP (Association for Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy in the NHS), The Balint Society, and the Royal College of General Practitioners. The participants were psychologists, psychotherapists, counsellors, GPs.
As is often the case with things named by psychotherapists, the title is a bit ambiguous, thought provoking. It was not about professionals troubling patients in troubling times, which is one possible reading. It was about, in part, patients troubled in these troubling times. Patients who bring their distress to the GP, the psychologist, the counsellor, the psychotherapist. ‘Troubling Times’: of course, this refers to the current context, with cuts in services, more pressure on the remaining services, with ‘reforms’ which are wolves clothed as lambs. But in some ways, all times are Troubling; but perhaps some more than others.
The introductory talk was given by Jan Wiener, a psychotherapist with many years experience of working in the primary care setting in partnership with GPs. Her talk, which I will not summarise, was entitled ‘Mindlessness in Troubled Times’. The title, I think, is enough to give pause for reflection.
We had a series of GP consultation vignettes, acted by the organising committee members which captured a wide variety of common primary care dilemmas and challenges. Some were troubling, some gave us to laugh.
Then small group work, a Balint group watched by the wider group, a small group Balint case discussion, and then a plenary session.
Many themes emerged. The ones I recall at this moment: with services being cut, there are people with significant distress who are then left without an important support; the importance of the work of psychologists/counsellors/psychotherapists; the central role of the GP; the importance of collaboration, communication; the (occasional, ? frequent) breakdown in communication between hospital and primary care; the mindlessness of some ‘reforms’, some protocols; a feeling of powerlessness in the face of the mindlessness (who do you take your concerns to? if your manager does not understand the work you do, what do you do?; and so on).
There was a sense that people had significant grievances which they needed to address to those in charge. I encouraged them to find out who these people were, to speak out, to protest. A few asked me about this blog. I gave them some advice about starting their own blogs. I wish them all the best.
One young GP voiced this: the bewilderment at the government asking us GPs to do things that make our job more difficult. Ah, yes, a familiar story.